Chapter INSTRUCTIONS FOR 「SUPERIOR ADULT「
CHAPTER XX
INSTRUCTIONS FOR 「SUPERIOR ADULT「
SUPERIOR ADULT, 1: VOCABULARY (SEVENTY-FIVE DEFINITIONS, 13,500 WORDS)
PROCEDURE and SCORING, as in previous vocabulary tests. At the 「superior adult「 level seventy-five words should be known.
The test is passed by only one third of those at the 「average adult「 level, but by about 90 per cent of 「superior adults.「 Ability to pass the test is relatively independent of the number of years the subject has attended school, our business men showing even a higher percentage of passes than high-school pupils.
SUPERIOR ADULT, 2: BINET'S PAPER-CUTTING TEST
PROCEDURE. Take a piece of paper about six inches square and say: 「Watch carefully what I do. See, I fold the paper this way (folding it once over in the middle), then I fold it this way (folding it again in the middle, but at right angles to the first fold). Now, I will cut out a notch right here「 (indicating). At this point take scissors and cut out a small notch from the middle of the side which presents but one edge. Throw the fragment which has been cut out into the waste-basket or under the table. Leave the folded paper exposed to view, but pressed flat against the table. Then give the subject a pencil and a second sheet of paper like the one already used and say: 「Take this piece of paper and make a drawing to show how the other sheet of paper would look if it were unfolded. Draw lines to show the creases in the paper and show what results from the cutting.「
The subject is not permitted to fold the second sheet, but must solve the problem by the imagination unaided.
Note that we do not say, 「Draw the holes,「 as this would inform the subject that more than one hole is expected.
SCORING. The test is passed if the creases in the paper are properly represented, if the holes are drawn in the correct number, and if they are located correctly, that is, both on the same crease and each about halfway between the center of the paper and the side. The shape of the holes is disregarded.
Failure may be due to error as regards the creases or the number and location of the holes, or it may involve any combination of the above errors.
REMARKS. Success seems to depend upon constructive visual imagination. The subject must first be able to construct in imagination the creases which result from the folding, and secondly, to picture the effects of the cutting as regards number of holes and their location. It appears that a solution is seldom arrived at, even in the case of college students, by logical mathematical thinking. Our unschooled subjects even succeeded somewhat better than high-school and college students of the same mental level.
Binet placed this test in year XIII of the 1908 scale, but shifted it to the adult group in the 1911 revision. Goddard retains it in the adult group, while Kuhlmann places it in year XV. There have also been certain variations in the procedure employed. As given in the Stanford revision the test is passed by hardly any subjects below the 14-year level, but by about one third of 「average adults「 and by the large majority of 「superior adults.「
SUPERIOR ADULT, 3: REPEATING EIGHT DIGITS
PROCEDURE and SCORING, the same as in previous tests with digits reversed. The series used are: 7-2-5-3-4-8-9-6; 4-9-8-5-3-7-6-2; and 8-3-7-9-5-4-8-2.
Guard against rhythm and grouping in reading the digits and do not give warning as to the number to be given.
The test is passed by about one third of 「average adults「 and by over two thirds of 「superior adults.「 The test shows no marked difference between educated and uneducated subjects of the same mental level.
SUPERIOR ADULT, 4: REPEATING THOUGHT OF PASSAGE
PROCEDURE. Say: 「I am going to read a little selection of about six or eight lines. When I am through I will ask you to repeat as much of it as you can. It doesn't make any difference whether you remember the exact words or not, but you must listen carefully so that you can tell me everything it says.「 Then read the following selections, pausing after each for the subject's report, which should be recorded verbatim:--
(a) 「Tests such as we are now making are of value both for the advancement of science and for the information of the person who is tested. It is important for science to learn how people differ and on what factors these differences depend. If we can separate the influence of heredity from the influence of environment, we may be able to apply our knowledge so as to guide human development. We may thus in some cases correct defects and develop abilities which we might otherwise neglect.「 (b) 「Many opinions have been given on the value of life. Some call it good, others call it bad. It would be nearer correct to say that it is mediocre; for on the one hand, our happiness is never as great as we should like, and on the other hand, our misfortunes are never as great as our enemies would wish for us. It is this mediocrity of life which prevents it from being radically unjust.「
Sometimes the subject hesitates to begin, thinking, in spite of our wording of the instructions, that a perfect reproduction is expected. Others fall into the opposite misunderstanding and think that they are prohibited from using the words of the text and must give the thought entirely in their own language. In cases of hesitation we should urge the subject a little and remind him that he is to express the thought of the selection in whatever way he prefers; that the main thing is to tell what the selection says.
SCORING. The test is passed if the subject is able to repeat in reasonably consecutive order the main thoughts of at least one of the selections. Neither elegance of expression nor verbatim repetition is expected. We merely want to know whether the leading thoughts in the selection have been grasped and remembered.
All grades of accuracy are found, both in the comprehension of the selection and in the recall, and it is not always easy to draw the line between satisfactory and unsatisfactory responses. The following sample performances will serve as a guide:--
Selection (a)
_Satisfactory._ 「The tests which we are making are given for the
advancement of science and for the information of the person
tested. By scientific means we will be able to separate
characteristics derived from heredity and environment and to
treat each class separately. By doing so we can more accurately
correct defects.「
「Tests like these are for two purposes. First to develop a
science, and second to apply it to the person to help him. The
tests are to find out how you differ from another and to measure
the difference between your heredity and environment.「
「These tests are given to see if we can separate heredity and
environment and to see if we can find out how one person differs
from another. We can then correct these differences and teach
people more effectively.「
「The tests that we are now making are valuable along both
scientific and personal lines. By using them it can be found out
where a person is weak and where he is strong. We can then
strengthen his weak points and remedy some things that would
otherwise be neglected. They are of great benefit to science and
to the person concerned.「
「Tests such as we are now making are of great importance because
they aim to show in what respects we differ from others and why,
and if they do this they will be able to guide us into the right
channel and bring success instead of failure.「
_Unsatisfactory._ 「Tests such as we are now making are of value
both for the advancement of science and for the information of
the person interested. It is necessary to know this.「
「Such tests as we are now making show about the human mind and
show in what channels we are fitted. It is the testing of each
individual between his effects of inheritancy and environment.「
「It is very interesting for us to study science for two reasons;
first, to test our mental ability, and second for the further
development of science.「
「Tests such as we are now making help in two ways; it helps the
scientists and it gives information to the people.「
「Tests are being given to pupils to-day to better them and to
aid science for generations to come. If each person knows
exactly his own beliefs and ideas and faults he can find out
exactly what kind of work he is fitted for by heredity. The
tests show that environment doesn't count, for if you are all
right you will get along anyway.「 (Note invention.)
Selection (b)
_Satisfactory._ 「There are different opinions about life. Some
call it good and some bad. It would be more correct to say that
it is middling, because we are never as happy as we would like
to be and we are never as sad as our enemies want us to be.「
「One hears many judgments about life. Some say it is good, while
others say it is bad. But it is really neither of the extremes.
Life is mediocre. We do not have as much good as we desire, nor
do we have as much misfortune as others want us to have.
Nevertheless, we have enough good to keep life from being
unjust.「
「Some people have different views of life from others. Some say
it is bad, others say it is good. It is better to class life as
mediocre, as it is never as good as we wish it, and on the other
hand, it might be worse.「
「Some people think differently of life. Some think it good, some
bad, others mediocre, which is nearest correct. It brings
unhappiness to us, but not as much as our enemies want us to
have.「
_Unsatisfactory._ 「Some say life is good, some say it is
mediocre. Even though some say it is mediocre they say it is
right.「
「There are two sides of life. Some say it is good while others
say it is bad. To some, life is happy and they get all they can
out of life. For others life is not happy and therefore they
fail to get all there is in life.「
「One hears many different judgments of life. Some call it good,
some call it bad. It brings unhappiness and it does not have
enough pleasure. It should be better distributed.「
「There are different opinions of the value of life. Some say it
is good and some say it is bad. Some say it is mediocrity. Some
think it brings happiness while others do not.「
「Nowadays there is much said about the value of life. Some say
it is good, while others say it is bad. A person should not have
an ill feeling toward the value of life, and he should not be
unjust to any one. Honesty is the best policy. People who are
unjust are more likely to be injured by their enemies.「 (Note
invention.)
REMARKS. Contrary to what the subject is led to expect, the test is less a test of memory than of ability to comprehend the drift of an abstract passage. A subject who fully grasps the meaning of the selection as it is read is not likely to fail because of poor memory. Mere verbal memory improves but little after the age of 14 or 15 years, as is shown by the fact that our adults do little better than eighth-grade children in repeating sentences of twenty-eight syllables. On the other hand, adult intelligence is vastly superior in the comprehension and retention of a logically presented group of abstract ideas.
There is nothing in which stupid persons cut a poorer figure than in grappling with the abstract. Their thinking clings tenaciously to the concrete; their concepts are vague or inaccurate; the interrelations among their concepts are scanty in the extreme; and such poor mental stores as they have are little available for ready use.
A few critics have objected to the use of tests demanding abstract thinking, on the ground that abstract thought is a very special aspect of intelligence and that facility in it depends almost entirely on occupational habits and the accidents of education. Some have even gone so far as to say that we are not justified, on the basis of any number of such tests, in pronouncing a subject backward or defective. It is supposed that a subject who has no capacity in the use of abstract ideas may nevertheless have excellent intelligence 「along other lines.「 In such cases, it is said, we should not penalize the subject for his failures in handling abstractions, but substitute, instead, tests requiring motor coördination and the manipulation of things, tests in which the supposedly dull child often succeeds fairly well.
From the psychological point of view, such a proposal is naïvely unpsychological. It is in the very essence of the higher thought processes to be conceptual and abstract. What the above proposal amounts to is, that if the subject is not capable of the more complex and strictly human type of thinking, we should ignore this fact and estimate his intelligence entirely on the ability he displays to carry on mental operations of a more simple and primitive kind. This would be like asking the physician to ignore the diseased parts of his patient's body and to base his diagnosis on an examination of the organs which are sound!
The present test throws light in an interesting way on the integrity of the critical faculty. Some subjects are unwilling to extend the report in the least beyond what they know to be approximately correct, while others with defective powers of auto-criticism manufacture a report which draws heavily on the imagination, perhaps continuing in garrulous fashion as long as they can think of anything having the remotest connection with any thought in the selection. We have included, for each selection, one illustration of this type in the sample failures given above.
The worst fault of the test is its susceptibility to the influence of schooling. Our uneducated adults of even 「superior adult「 intelligence often fail, while about two thirds of high-school pupils succeed. The unschooled adults have a marked tendency either to give a summary which is inadequate because of its extreme brevity, or else to give a criticism of the thought which the passage contains.
This test first appeared in Binet's 1911 revision, in the adult group. Binet used only selection (b), and in a slightly more difficult form than we have given above. Goddard gives the test like Binet and retains it in the adult group. Kuhlmann locates it in year XV, using only selection (a). On the basis of over 300 tests of adults we find the test too difficult for the 「average adult「 level, even on the basis of only one success in two trials and when scored on the rather liberal standard above set forth.
SUPERIOR ADULT, 5: REPEATING SEVEN DIGITS REVERSED
PROCEDURE and SCORING, the same as in previous tests of this kind. The series are: 4-1-6-2-5-9-3; 3-8-2-6-4-7-5; and 9-4-5-2-8-3-7.
We have collected fewer data on this test than on any of the others, as it was added later to the test series. As far as we have used it we have found few 「average adults「 who pass, while about half the 「superior adults「 do so.
SUPERIOR ADULT, 6: INGENUITY TEST
PROCEDURE. Problem a is stated as follows:--
_A mother sent her boy to the river and told him to bring back
exactly 7 pints of water. She gave him a 3-pint vessel and a
5-pint vessel. Show me how the boy can measure out exactly
7 pints of water, using nothing but these two vessels and not
guessing at the amount. You should begin by filling the 5-pint
vessel first. Remember, you have a 3-pint vessel and a 5-pint
vessel and you must bring back exactly 7 pints._
The problem is given orally, but may be repeated if necessary.
The subject is not allowed pencil or paper and is requested to give his solution orally as he works it out. It is then possible to make a complete record of the method employed.
The subject is likely to resort to some such method as to 「fill the 3-pint vessel two thirds full,「 or, 「I would mark the inside of the 5-pint vessel so as to show where 4 pints come to,「 etc. We inform the subject that such a method is not allowable; that this would be guessing, since he could not be sure when the 3-pint vessel was two thirds full (or whether he had marked off his 5-pint vessel accurately). Tell him he must measure out the water without any guesswork. Explain also, that it is a fair problem, not a 「catch.「
Say nothing about pouring from one vessel to another, but if the subject asks whether this is permissible the answer is 「yes.「
The time limit for each problem is 5 minutes. If the subject fails on the first problem, we explain the solution in full and then proceed to the next.
The second problem is like the first, except that a 5-pint vessel and a 7-pint vessel are given, to get 8 pints, the subject being told to begin by filling the 5-pint vessel.
In the third problem 4 and 9 are given, to get 7, the instruction being to 「begin by filling the 4-pint vessel.「
Note that in each problem we instruct the subject how to begin. This is necessary in order to secure uniformity of conditions. It is possible to solve all of the problems by beginning with either of the two vessels, but the solution is made very much more difficult if we begin in the direction opposite from that recommended.
Give no further aid. It is necessary to refrain from comment of every kind.
SCORING. Two of the three problems must be solved correctly within the 5 minutes allotted to each.
REMARKS. We have called this a test of ingenuity. The subject who is given the problem finds himself involved in a difficulty from which he must extricate himself. Means must be found to overcome an obstacle. This requires practical judgement and a certain amount of inventive ingenuity. Various possibilities must be explored and either accepted for trial or rejected. If the amount of invention called for seems to the reader inconsiderable, let it be remembered that the important inventions of history have not as a rule had a Minerva birth, but instead have developed by successive stages, each involving but a small step in advance.
It is unnecessary to emphasize at length the function of invention in the higher thought processes. In one form or another it is present in all intellectual activity; in the creation and use of language, in art, in social adjustments, in religion, and in philosophy, as truly as in the domains of science and practical affairs. Certainly this is true if we accept Mason's broad definition of invention as including 「every change in human activity made designedly and systematically.「[78] From the psychological point of view, perhaps, Mason is justified in looking upon the great inventor as 「an epitome of the genius of the world.「 To develop a Krag-Joergensen from a bow and arrow, a 「velvet-tipped「 lucifer match from the primitive fire-stick, or a modern piano from the first crude, stringed, musical instrument has involved much the same intellectual processes as have been operative in transforming fetishism and magic into religion and philosophy, or scattered fragments of knowledge into science.
[78] Otis T. Mason: The Origins of Inventions. (London, 1902.)
Psychologically, invention depends upon the constructive imagination; that is, upon the ability to abstract from what is immediately present to the senses and to picture new situations with their possibilities and consequences. Images are united in order to form new combinations.
As we have several times emphasized, the decisive intellectual differences among human beings are not greatly dependent upon mere sense discrimination or native retentiveness. Far more important than the raw mass of sense data is the correct shooting together of the sense elements in memory and imagination. This is but another name for invention. It is the synthetic, or apperceptive, activity of the mind that gives the 「seven-league boots「 to genius. It is, however, a kind of ability which is possessed by all minds to a greater or less degree. Any test has its value which gives a clue, as this test does, to the subject's ability in this direction.
The test was devised by the writer and used in 1905 in a study of the intellectual processes of bright and dull boys, but it was not at that time standardized. It has been found to belong at a much higher mental level than was at first supposed. Only an insignificant number pass the test below the mental age of 14 years, and about two thirds of 「average adults「 fail. Of our 「superior adults「 somewhat more than 75 per cent succeed. Formal education influences the test little or not at all, the unschooled business men making a somewhat better showing than the high-school students.
SELECTED REFERENCES
The following classified lists include only the most important references under each topic. So many investigations have been made with the Binet-Simon tests in the last few years, and so many articles have been written in evaluation of the method, that a complete bibliography of the subject would require thirty or forty pages. Those who desire to make a more thorough study of the literature are referred to the admirable annotated bibliography compiled by Samuel C. Kohs, and published by Warwick & York, Baltimore. Kohs's Bibliography contains 254 references, and is complete to January 1, 1914.
BINET-SIMON TESTS OF NORMAL CHILDREN
-
Binet, A., et Simon, Th. 「Le développement de l'intelligence chez les enfants「; in Année psychologique (1908), vol. 14, pp. 1-94.
Exposition of the original 1908 scale with results.
-
Binet, A. 「Nouvelles recherches sur la mesure du niveau intellectuel chez les enfants d'école「; in Année psychologique (1911), vol. 17, pp. 145-201.
Presents the 1911 revision.
-
Bobertag, O. 「Ueber Intelligenzprüfungen (nach der Methode von Binet und Simon)「; in Zeitschrift für angewande Psychologie (1911), vol. 5, pp. 105-203; and (1912), vol. 6, pp. 495-537.
Analysis of 400 cases and criticism of method and results.
-
Dougherty, M. L. 「Report on the Binet-Simon Tests given to Four Hundred and Eighty-three Children in the Public Schools of Kansas City, Kansas「; in Journal of Educational Psychology (1913), vol. 4, pp. 338-52.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「The Binet-Simon Measuring Scale for Intelligence, Revised「; in Training School Bulletin (1911), vol. 8, pp. 56-62.
-
Hoffman, A. 「Vergleichende Intelligenzprüfungen an Vorschülern und Volksschülern「; in Zeitschrift für angewande Psychologie (1913), vol. 8, pp. 102-20.
One hundred and fifty-six subjects. Ages seven, nine, and ten.
-
Johnston, Katherine L. 「Binet's Method for the Measurement of Intelligence; Some Results「; in Journal of Experimental Pedagogy (1911), vol. 1, pp. 24-31.
Results of 200 tests of school children.
-
Kuhlmann, F. 「Some Results of Examining 1000 Public-School Children with a Revision of the Binet-Simon Tests of Intelligence by Untrained Teachers「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1914), vol. 18, pp. 150-79, and 233-69.
-
Phillips, Byron A. 「The Binet Tests applied to Colored Children「; in Psychological Clinic (1914), pp. 190-96.
A comparison of 86 colored and 137 white children.
-
Rogers, Agnes L., and McIntyre, J. L. 「The Measurement of Intelligence in Children by the Binet-Simon Scale「; in British Journal of Psychology (1914), vol. 7, pp. 265-300.
-
Rowe, E. C. 「Five Hundred Forty-Seven White and Two Hundred Sixty-Eight Indian Children tested by the Binet-Simon Tests「; in Pedagogical Seminary (1914), vol. 21, pp. 454-69.
-
Strong, Alice C. 「Three Hundred Fifty White and Colored Children measured by the Binet-Simon Measuring Scale of Intelligence「; in Pedagogical Seminary (1913), vol. 20, pp. 485-515.
-
Terman, L. M., and Childs, H. G. 「A Tentative Revision and Extension of the Binet-Simon Measuring Scale of Intelligence「; in Journal of Educational Psychology (1912), vol. 3, pp. 61-74, 133-43, 198-208, and 277-89.
Results of 396 tests of California school-children.
-
Terman, Lyman, Ordahl, Galbreath, and Talbert. The Stanford Revision and Extension of the Binet-Simon Measuring Scale of Intelligence. (1916.)
Detailed analysis of the results secured by testing 1000 unselected school-children within two months of a birthday.
-
Weintrob, J. and R. 「The Influence of Environment on Mental Ability as shown by the Binet Tests「; in Journal of Educational Psychology (1912), pp. 577-86.
-
Winch, W. H. 「Binet's Mental Tests: What They Are, and What We Can Do with Them「; in Child Study (London), 1913, 1914, 1915, and 1916.
An extended series of articles setting forth results of tests with normal children, and giving valuable criticisms and suggestions.
BINET-SIMON TESTS OF THE FEEBLE-MINDED
-
Chotzen, F. 「Die Intelligenzprüfungsmethode von Binet-Simon bei schwachsinnigen Kindern「; in Zeitschrift für angewande Psychologie (1912), vol. 6, pp. 411-94.
A critical study of the results of 280 tests.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「Four Hundred Feeble-Minded Children classified by the Binet Method「; in Pedagogical Seminary (1910), vol. 17, pp. 387-97; also in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1910), vol. 15, pp. 17-30.
Offers important evidence of the value of the Binet-Simon method.
-
Kuhlmann, F. 「The Binet and Simon Tests of Intelligence in Grading Feeble-Minded Children「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1912), vol. 16, pp. 173-93.
Analysis of results from 1300 cases.
BINET-SIMON TESTS OF DELINQUENTS
-
Bluemel, C. S. 「Binet Tests on Two Hundred Juvenile Delinquents「; in Training School Bulletin (1915), pp. 187-93.
-
Goddard, H. H. The Criminal Imbecile. The Macmillan Company. (1915.) 157 pages.
An analysis of the mentality of three murderers of moron or borderline intelligence.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「The Responsibility of Children in the Juvenile Court「; in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (September, 1912).
Analysis of 100 tests of juvenile delinquents.
-
Healy, William. The Individual Delinquent. Little, Brown & Co. (1915.) 830 pages.
A textbook on delinquents. Gives results of many Binet-Simon tests.
-
Spaulding, Edith R. 「The Results of Mental and Physical Examination of Four Hundred Women Offenders「; in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1915), pp. 704-17.
-
Sullivan, W. C. 「La mesure du développement intellectuel chez les jeunes délinquantes「; in Année psychologique (1912), vol. 18, pp. 341-61.
-
Williams, J. Harold. A Study of 150 Delinquent Boys. Bulletin no. 1, Research Laboratory of the Buckel Foundation. (1915.) 15 pages.
The Stanford revision used. Report of over 400 cases to follow.
BINET-SIMON TESTS OF SUPERIOR CHILDREN
-
Jeronutti, A. 「Ricerche psicologiche sperimentali sugli alunni molto intelligenti「; in Lab. di Psicol. Sperim. della Reg. Univ. Roma. (1912)
Out of fifteen hundred school and kindergarten children, ages five to twelve, fourteen were selected by the teachers as the brightest. The Binet test showed them to be from one to three years in advance of their chronological ages.
-
Terman, L. M. 「The Mental Hygiene of Exceptional Children「; in Pedagogical Seminary (1915), vol. 22, pp. 529-37.
Data on 31 children testing above 120 I. Q.
INSTRUCTIONS FOR GIVING THE BINET-SIMON TESTS
-
Binet, A., and Simon, Th. A Method of Measuring the Development of Intelligence in Young Children. Chicago Medical Book Company. (1915.) 82 pages.
Authorized translation of Binet's final instructions for giving the tests.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「A Measuring Scale of Intelligence「; in Training School Bulletin (1910), vol. 6, pp. 146-55.
Condensed translation of Binet's 1908 Measuring Scale of Intelligence.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「The Binet-Simon Measuring Scale for Intelligence, Revised「; in Training School Bulletin (1911), vol. 8, pp. 56-62.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「Standard Method for Giving the Binet Test「; in Training School Bulletin (1913), vol. 10, pp. 23-30.
-
Kuhlmann, F. 「A Revision of the Binet-Simon System for Measuring the Intelligence of Children「; Monograph Supplement of Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (September, 1912), 41 pages.
-
Wallin, J. E. W. 「A Practical Guide for the Administration of the Binet-Simon Scale for Measuring Intelligence「; in The Psychological Clinic (1911), vol. 5, pp. 217-38.
CRITICISMS AND EVALUATIONS OF THE BINET-SIMON METHOD
-
Berry, C. S. 「A Comparison of the Binet Tests of 1908 and 1911「; in Journal of Educational Psychology (1912), vol. 3, pp. 444-51.
-
Bobertag, O. 「Ueber Intelligenzprüfungen (nach der Methode von Binet und Simon)「; in Zeitschrift für angewande Psychologie. (A, 1911), vol. 5, pp. 105-203; (B, 1912), vol. 6, pp. 495-537.
Accepts the method and gives valuable suggestions for improvement.
-
Brigham, Carl C. 「An Experimental Critique of the Binet-Simon Scale「; in Journal of Educational Psychology (1914), pp. 439-48.
Finds the scale 96% efficient.
-
Goddard, H. H. 「The Reliability of the Binet-Simon Measuring Scale of Intelligence「; in Proceedings of the Fourth International Congress of School Hygiene (1913), vol. 5, pp. 693-99.
Application of the theory of probability to the results proves the extremely small liability of error.
-
Kohs, Samuel C. 「The Practicability of the Binet Scale and the Question of the Borderline Case「; in Training School Bulletin (1916), pp. 211-23.
Analysis of cases showing the reliability of the scale.
-
Kuhlmann, F. 「Binet and Simon's System for Measuring the Intelligence of Children「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1911), vol. 15, pp. 79-92.
Finds the method of the greatest value.
-
Kuhlmann, F. 「A Reply to Dr. L. P. Ayres's Criticism of the Binet and Simon System for Measuring the Intelligence of Children「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1911), vol. 16, pp. 58-67.
Many of the Ayres criticisms are shown to be unfounded.
-
Meumann, E. Vorlesungen zur Einführung in die Experimentelle Pädagogik (1913), vol. 2, pp. 130-300.
Summary of the literature on Binet tests up to 1913. Accepts the method but gives suggestions for improvement. This summary and other writings of Meumann on the psychology of endowment are reviewed by Lewis M. Terman in a series of four articles in the Journal of Psycho-Asthenics for 1915.
-
Otis, A. S. 「Some Logical and Mathematical Aspects of the Measurement of Intelligence by the Binet-Simon Method「; in The Psychological Review (April and June, 1916).
Considers the Binet-Simon method imperfect from the mathematical point of view.
-
Schmitt, Clara. Standardization of Tests for Defective Children. Psychological Monographs (1915), no. 83, 181 pages.
Contains (pp. 52-67) a discussion of the 「Fallacies and Inadequacies of the Binet-Simon Series.「 Most of the criticisms here given are either superficial or unfair, some of them apparently being due to a lack of acquaintance with Binet's writings.
-
Stern, W. The Psychological Methods of Measuring Intelligence. Translated by G. M. Whipple. (1913.) 160 pages.
A splendid critical discussion of the Binet-Simon method. Should be read by every one who would use the scale.
-
Terman, L. M. 「Suggestions for Revising, Extending, and Supplementing the Binet Intelligence Tests「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1913), vol. 18, pp. 20-33.
-
Terman, L. M. 「Psychological Principles Underlying the Binet-Simon Scale and Some Practical Considerations for its Correct Use「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (1913), vol. 18, pp. 93-104.
-
Terman, L. M. 「A Report of the Buffalo Conference on the Binet-Simon Tests of Intelligence「; in Pedagogical Seminary (1913), vol. 20, pp. 549-54.
Abstracts of papers presented at the above conference.
-
Terman, Lyman, Ordahl, Galbreath, and Talbert. The Stanford Revision and Extension of the Binet-Simon Scale for Measuring Intelligence. (1916.)
Contains a chapter on the validity of the individual tests and on considerations relating to the formation of an intelligence scale.
-
Terman and Knollin. 「The Detection of Borderline Deficiency by the Binet-Simon Method「; in Journal of Psycho-Asthenics (June, 1916).
A comparison of the accuracy of the Stanford and other revisions with borderline cases.
-
Trèves and Saffiotti. 「L'échelle métrique de l'intelligence modifiée selon la méthode Trèves-Saffiotti「; in Année Psychologique (1912), pp. 327-40.
Criticize the age-grade method of measuring intelligence and propose a substitute.
-
Wallin, J. E. W. Experimental Studies of Mental Defectives. A Critique of the Binet-Simon Tests. Warwick & York. (1912.)
Criticism based on the use of the scale with epileptics.
-
Yerkes and Bridges. A Point Scale for Measuring Mental Ability. Warwick & York.
Authors think the point scale preferable to the Binet-Simon method.
BOOKS ON MENTAL DEFICIENCY
-
Binet, A., and Simon, Th. Mentally Defective Children. Translated from the French by W. B. Drummond. Longmans, Green & Co. (1914.) 171 pages.
Discusses the psychology, pedagogy, and medical examination of defectives.
-
Goddard, H. H. Feeble-Mindedness; Its Causes and Consequences. The Macmillan Company. (1913.) 599 pages.
The most important single volume on the subject. Extensive data on the causes of feeble-mindedness and excellent clinical pictures of all grades of mental defects.
-
Goddard, H. H. The Kallikak Family. The Macmillan Company. (1914.) 121 pages.
An epoch-making study of the hereditary transmission of mental deficiency in a degenerate family.
-
Holmes, Arthur. The Conservation of the Child. J. B. Lippincott Company. (1912.) 345 pages.
Methods of examination and treatment of defective children.
-
Holmes, Arthur. The Backward Child. Bobbs-Merrill Company. (1915.)
A popular treatment of the handling of backward children.
-
Huey, E. B. Backward and Feeble-Minded Children. Warwick & York. (1912.) 221 pages.
Devoted mainly to clinical accounts of borderline cases.
-
Lapage, C. P. Feeble-Mindedness in Children of School Age. The University Press, Manchester, England. (1911.) 359 pages.
-
Sherlock, E. B. The Feeble-Minded; A Guide to Study and Practice. The Macmillan Company. (1911.) 327 pages.
-
Tredgold, A. F. Mental Deficiency (Amentia). Baillière, Tindall, and Cox. London, England. (2d ed. 1914.) 491 pages.
The best medical treatment of the subject.
STUDIES OF THE PROGRESS OF CHILDREN THROUGH THE GRADES
-
Ayres, Leonard P. Laggards in our Schools. The Russell Sage Foundation. (1909.) 236 pages.
Interesting and instructive discussion of school retardation and its causes.
-
Blan, Louis B. A Special Study of the Incidence of Retardation. Teachers College, Columbia University, Contributions to Education, no. 40. (1911.) 111 pages.
Review of the literature and a statistical study of the progress of 4579 children.
-
Keyes, C. H. Progress Through the Grades of City Schools. Teachers College, Columbia University, Contributions to Education, no. 42. (1911.) 79 pages.
Important study of the progress of several thousand children.
-
Strayer, George D. Age and Grade Census of Schools and Colleges. Bulletin no. 451, U.S. Bureau of Education. (1911.) 144 pages.
Statistics of the age-grade status of the children in 318 cities.
-
See also the Reports of leading school surveys, such as those of New York, Salt Lake City, Butte, Springfield (Mass.), Denver, Cleveland, etc.
REFERENCES ON THE SPECIAL CLASS FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN
-
Huey, E. B. 「The Education of Defectives and the Training of Teachers for Special Classes「; in Journal of Educational Psychology (1913), pp. 545-50.
-
Goddard, H. H. School Training of Defective Children. World
